Wanted: Franchise Quarterback

The Vikings will tell you that Matt Cassel only played because Christian Ponder was hurt, everyone else will tell you the truth, it was time for a change.

Given every chance to succeed and complete confidence from the team, coaching staff, and his teammates, Christian Ponder has shown he does not have what it takes to be a successful NFL quarterback.

Matt Cassel isn’t going to the Pro Bowl, but on Sunday he showed that he deserves to be a starting quarterback. He looked decisive, threw the ball with the velocity, and took chances downfield. Three things Christian Ponder either can’t or won’t do.

Matt Cassel is just another name in the long list of veteran free agent quarterbacks to become starters for the Vikings. The Vikings have relied on free agency to find their starting quarterbacks going back to the 80s. Since Tommy Kramer was let go following the ’86 season, the Vikings have drafted four quarterbacks, and rarely have things worked out. Christian Ponder failing is disappointing but it shouldn’t be surprising.

Rich Gannon was drafted in 1987, didn’t start a game until 1990, and was no longer on the team following the 1992 season. He was selected in the fourth round so this kind of career arc is not surprising.

Daunte Culpepper was drafted 1999, became the starting quarterback in 2000, went to three Pro Bowls, suffered a devastating knee injury, and forced a trade which sent him to Miami in 2006. Easily one of the best quarterbacks the Vikings drafted, Culpepper might still be playing had he not been injured and decided to become his own agent.

Tarvaris Jackson was drafted in 2006, started 20 games over the next five years, and was let go following the 2010 season. Never looked like a starting NFL quarterback, played like one once or twice.

Christian Ponder was drafted in 2011, underwhelmed his rookie season, underwhelmed in 2012, and was benched is currently nursing an injured rib on the sidelines. Pundits and fans scratched their heads when he was drafted and they still are.

Rich Gannon was never plan A, Daunte Culpepper was almost a franchise quarterback, Tarvaris Jackson was a mistake, and Christian Ponder would make a fine back up.

Other than Culpepper, the other draft choices were poor selections. No one but Brad Childress saw Jackson as a starting quarterback and no one saw Ponder as one except for the Vikings.

The coaches have changed, the front office has changed, but the situation has not. The Vikings are still looking for their franchise quarterback and they have wasted the prime years of Adrian Peterson’s career looking for their guy.

At some point the Vikings need to find a quarterback that can effectively play the position for several years. Signing a different veteran from year to year to cover for an inability to draft might win some games, but it won’t win you any Super Bowls.

After this season Christian Ponder will be gone and the Vikings will back in the mix to draft a quarterback. If history is any indication, they will probably pick the wrong guy. Other teams will draft Pro Bowlers, future hall of famers, and day one starters while the Vikings will be stuck with a passer they need to make excuses for until they find excuses to bench him.

Maybe they don’t get good enough draft picks, maybe they are unlucky, or maybe the truth is that the Vikings haven’t seen a franchise quarterback in Minnesota for so long that no one knows what one looks like.

Marcus Sherels: Just doing his job

Usually when you lose there is something positive you can pull out of it, regardless of the final score. Sunday’s game against the Browns left the Vikings with very little to be positive about. The defense couldn’t stop a 3^rd string quarterback, the offense faltered in the red zone (again), and the special teams allowed the Browns to score a touchdown on a fake field goal and gain 34 yards on a fake punt. Combined with 3 untimely turnovers, it was difficult to watch.

The only positive thing the Vikings can take from this game is the play of Marcus Sherels. He led the team with 8 tackles, 2 passes defended, and made a critical tackle on a fake punt, which would have gone for a touchdown had he not made the play. He wasn’t perfect, he did fumble the ball once and you would much prefer your defensive backs to record interceptions instead of tackles, but he didn’t give up any big plays on defense and made several impressive plays in the open field.

Forced into a much larger defensive role following injuries to starter Chris Cook and backup, A.J. Jefferson, Sherels played much better than anyone expected. For a guy that keeps finding a way to stay on the roster he played extremely well.

Marcus Sherels came to the Vikings as an undrafted free agent in 2010. He was assigned to the practice, then cut from the practice squad, then resigned to the practice squad, and finally added the active roster all during the 2010 season. The next two seasons he remained on the roster as a return man/backup cornerback and his spot on the roster was as safe as it could be for a player who is primarily a special teamer. In training camp this season the Vikings brought in Bobby Felder to compete with Sherels, following training camp and a few preseason games, Felder was winning the competition.

During the final preseason game Sherels returned a kickoff 109 yards for a score and intercepted a pass, while Felder suffered a serious ankle injury, ending any competition for Sherels' job.

During the game against the Browns, Sherels once again played his best when the pressure was on. Forced into a much larger role, he far outplayed expectations and didn’t let the spotlight affect him. It speaks volumes for him but it also speaks volumes for the rest of the defense. When the pressure has risen, they have wilted.

When needing one stop with the game on the line, two weeks in a row the defense has failed. The Vikings have sack leaders, consecutive pro-bowlers, and first round draft picks and on Sunday their best player was an undersized, undrafted, backup. The rest of the defense needs to start playing like their jobs are on the line, they need to start playing like they might not get another chance, they need to start playing like Marcus Sherels.

Sunday Rundown: Week 2

MIN 30 – CHI 31: What do minimal defensive adjustments late in the 4^th, poor play calling in the red zone, and a huge gaffe on special teams mean? Bad coaching.

WSH 20 – GB 38: RG3 isn’t back to form and might never get back if he stays on the field. He has been taking some vicious hits and his poor play isn’t helping his confidence or his team.

DET 21 – ARI 24: Arizona kicked a bunch of field goals and the Lions committed a bunch of penalties. Cardinals win.

CAR 23 – BUF 24: EJ Manuel led a great drive at the end and Carolina handed Buffalo the victory by leaving Stevie Johnson wide open with 2 seconds left. Nice way for the Bills’ rookie qb to get his first win.

STL 24 – ATL 31: The Rams and Falcons didn’t care much for running the ball in this one. In the end Matt Ryan and the Falcons beat Sam Bradford’s Rams in a shootout.

MIA 24 – IND 20: Mike Wallace, the Dolphins expensive offseason acquisition, recorded 9 catches, 115 yards receiving, and td after failing to catch a pass in week one.

CLE 6 – BAL 14: The Ravens defense is pretty good but the Browns offense is pretty bad.

TEN 24 – HOU 30: DeAndre Hopkins lassoed a Matt Schaub pass to beat the Titans in overtime. Jake Locker was efficient but the Titans need him bigger plays from him if they want to win.

JAX 9 – OAK 19: Jacksonville rushed for 34 yards, Oakland rushed for 224. Can you guess who won?

TB 14 – NO 16: 118 yards of penalties by Tampa Bay and a Garrett Hartley field goal at the end is all the Saints needed to put away the Buccaneers in a game interrupted by an extended delay due to lightning.

DEN 41 – NYG 21: Peyton doubled his little brother’s quarterback rating and the Broncos almost doubled the Giants point total.

DAL 16 – KC 17: DeMarco Murray rushed for 24 yards while Alex Smith ran for 57. Most the time when your opponent’s quarterback outrushes your running back, you are going to lose.

SD 33 – PHI 30: The Chargers offense played like Chip Kelly was coaching them and the Eagles couldn’t keep up. Philly missed a chip shot field goal in the final two minutes, which led to a Nick Novak game winning kick with only a few seconds left.

SEA 30 – SAN 3: The Seahawks defense and the 12^th man in the stands forced Colin Kaepernick into one of his worst games as a pro. Sure he ran for 87 yards but he also completed less than half of his passes and threw 3 picks.

Adrian still in need of assistance

Sunday’s game between the Minnesota Vikings and the Detroit Lions made one thing abundantly clear: Adrian Peterson needs help.

After rushing for 78 yards and a score on their first offensive possession, Peterson gained a paltry 15 yards on the ground through the final three quarters combined. After his first carry of the game, Peterson averaged less than a yard on his next 17. For a player of Peterson’s caliber, 15 yards over three quarters is unacceptable and frankly an embarrassment for the reigning MVP.

Peterson hasn’t lost anything from last season, he still runs with all the same speed, power, and determination he always has. His lead blocker, Jerome Felton, returns from suspension after Week Three. Felton will give the running game a boost but the Vikings won’t be catching a break from any of the teams on their schedule. The Lions’ strategy for stopping Peterson will be the same one employed by every other team on the schedule unless the Vikings prove they can effectively throw the ball. Peterson will be fighting through eight defenders aggressively attacking him and closing off running lanes every time he touches the ball.

For Peterson to even get close to his goal of 2500 yards and for the Vikings to even get close to the playoffs, the Vikings offense needs to drastically improve. The offensive line needs to block better, the play calling needs to improve, and most of all, the quarterback needs to play better.  The Vikings don’t need their quarterback to be spectacular, they don’t even need him to be good, they just need him to be average.  On Sunday, Christian Ponder was none of these.  He stared down his receivers, he was inaccurate, and he didn’t take care of the football. He was awful.

In the offseason, the Vikings added pieces to improve their receiving corps by signing Greg Jennings and drafting Cordarrelle Patterson. Losing Percy Harvin was a big blow but Jennings and Patterson combined are more than capable of replacing his production. The new additions, along with the development of Kyle Rudolph and Jerome Simpson, give the Vikings a receiving corps any starting NFL quarterback should be able to succeed with. Through the preseason and Game One of the regular season, Ponder has shown he isn’t up to the task.

The Vikings brought in Matt Cassel as an insurance policy in case Ponder floundered and it looks like he might be replacing Ponder sooner rather than later. The problem for Peterson and the Vikings is that Cassel is only a slight upgrade over Ponder.

Cassel’s and Ponder’s career averages are fairly close, with a slight edge to Cassel. They both average close to 6.5 yards per passing attempt, they both complete a shade under 60% of their passes, and they both average less than 200 yards passing per game. Their quarterback ratings are 4 points apart with the edge going to Cassel. So when Ponder gets benched in favor of Cassel, the Vikings won’t necessarily be getting a better quarterback, they will just be getting a different quarterback.

Unfortunately for Peterson, this has been the case at quarterback his entire career, minus #4’s first magical season. The Vikings are making the same mistake with Christian Ponder that they did with Tarvaris Jackson. They drafted him too high, they made him their starting quarterback, and they waited too long to admit they were wrong.

Peterson has only so much time left until he starts regressing, two or three years tops. He has carried the load for the Vikings since being drafted and has only played with a quality passer for one season, a season that took the Vikings to the NFC Championship Game. It might be too late this year but the Vikings need to get a starting quarterback to help Peterson and maximize his superhuman abilities while they still can.

He might go down as the best running back in NFL history and he might wind up as the NFL’s all time leading rusher. If he had played alongside a legitimate starting quarterback during the majority of his career? We wouldn’t be saying might.